July 12, 2024


Good Living

Monorail between Montgomery and Frederick counties would generate billions in financial rewards, examine claims

A 27-mile monorail together Interstate 270 concerning Shady Grove and Frederick in Maryland would make practically $4 billion far more in financial positive aspects above a few many years than it would cost to establish and run, in accordance to a new study funded by monorail supporters.


The line would conserve time — and, in change, money — both for monorail travellers and motorists who would love much less congestion on I-270, the review found. A monorail also would raise small business productivity and make the Washington location extra economically competitive.

The examine by Boston-primarily based economic consulting agency EBP is component of developer Robert O. Eisinger’s quest to persuade the Maryland Division of Transportation to create a monorail in between Montgomery and Frederick counties. Eisinger’s professional-monorail Higher Highway Foundation funded the $68,000 review, generally with his own dollars, he claimed. The group previously funded engineering and vacation need analyses of the proposal.

“First we proved you could physically do it, then we proved there’s a demand for it,” claimed Eisinger, a handling member at Rockville-based Promark Companions. “We’ve just proved that, economically, you just cannot manage not to do this.”

[A Montgomery developer’s plan to ease traffic on I-270: Build monorail]

He said he has not still shared the conclusions with MDOT.

Even though Eisinger explained the monorail could complement Maryland Gov. Larry Hogan’s (R) strategy to create toll lanes on I-270, state transportation officials have not dedicated to which includes it in their approaching environmental evaluate of the lanes north of Interstate 370.

MDOT spokeswoman Erin Henson mentioned the company is nevertheless devising the “preliminary alternatives” that will be analyzed. Nonetheless, she said, the state is accomplishing its own “monorail feasibility study” that will be unveiled later on this fall.

“As studies have proven, the nationwide capital region can profit from several options, which include improved telework, transit, and managed [toll] lanes for long-expression congestion reduction,” Henson explained in an e mail. “We are committed to acquiring all probable options to ease congestion for the citizens of Maryland.”

Eisinger reported he knows some men and women will scoff at the idea of an elevated monorail whizzing over I-270 website traffic. He’s listened to the Disney Entire world jokes.

[Study: Using express toll lanes on I-270 could mean paying $50 between Frederick and Shady Grove]

But he and other area monorail supporters stage to more than 40 monorail methods around the world, and Eisinger mentioned he’s read a “significant amount of political support” from the Montgomery County Council and point out lawmakers. When MDOT has not committed to the strategy, Eisinger claimed, “I’m not obtaining any negative opinions from them.”

Del. Kumar P. Barve (D-Montgomery), chairman of the Property Environment and Transportation Committee, claimed he grew to become intrigued with Eisinger’s strategy soon after holding a listening to on it in January.

He reported he was significantly amazed that a monorail would match in I-270’s appropriate of way, allowing for it to stay clear of the controversy that usually kills transportation assignments that impact households and other adjacent properties.

“I personally feel any approach that does not call for the acquisition of land would be a winner right from the start,” Barve stated.

[Maryland towns ready to fight maglev project as federal review stalls]

Creating a monorail and then working and keeping it above 28 a long time would charge $2.7 billion, the study discovered. Development would charge $3.6 billion, but some of that price would stay in the technique at the conclude of the 28 many years, the analysts explained.

In the meantime, the economic benefits of more rapidly, safer and extra reliable travel would arrive to $6.6 billion, leaving an in general $3.9 billion gain, the review observed.

“When you operate the numbers, you see the advantages clearly outweighing the prices,” said Naomi Stein, a person of the study’s authors.

Underneath Eisinger’s proposal, the monorail would operate involving the Frederick MARC commuter rail station and the Shady Grove Metro station in Rockville, with stations in Urbana, Clarksburg, Germantown and Metropolitan Grove.

Clustering new households and employment around monorail stations would aid the area mature in a a lot more sustainable and environmentally helpful way, Eisinger said. His organization owns property across the Washington location, he mentioned, but not at any of the proposed monorail stations.

The review assumed monorail trains would get there just about every 6 minutes through the morning and night hurry and each individual 12 minutes off-peak. The trip amongst Frederick and Shady Grove was assumed to consider about 47 minutes with an normal pace of 35 miles per hour, in accordance to a earlier basis-funded research by Massachusetts-dependent Cambridge Systematics. Such a circumstance would attract about 34,800 travellers day by day in the 1st calendar year, that evaluation mentioned.

[A lot of cities, including D.C., want roboshuttles. But will they work?]

Eisinger explained he believes a monorail could be built and operated via a general public-personal partnership with teams of corporations funding its building and functioning it in exchange for condition payments to include their financial debt, charges and a financial gain.

Eisinger stated he’s anxious about the new dissolution of Maryland’s $5.6 billion community-non-public partnership on the state’s gentle-rail Purple Line project. Nevertheless, he reported, for the reason that a monorail wouldn’t need additional right of way or utility relocations, it would have a significantly reduce threat of the types of expense overruns that have plagued the Purple Line challenge.

Examine extra:

a train is parked on the side of a road: A rendering of a monorail that Montgomery County developer Robert L. Eisinger of Promark Partners is exploring. He has hired engineering consultants to study the possibility of building the 27-mile monorail system between Shady Grove and Frederick.

© Illustration by Interface Multimedia, courtesy of The Substantial Road Foundation
A rendering of a monorail that Montgomery County developer Robert L. Eisinger of Promark Companions is checking out. He has employed engineering consultants to review the probability of making the 27-mile monorail technique among Shady Grove and Frederick.

a train traveling down train tracks next to a highway: The monorail would fit into the footprint of I-270.

© Illustration by Interface Multimedia, courtesy of The Superior Street Basis
The monorail would healthy into the footprint of I-270.

Carry on Looking at